Lehigh Valley news. Straight up.

Allentown police retirement deal: keeping officers or draining reserves?

The police union is suing City Council over a delayed plan to keep veteran officers on the job.

Hyperrealistic editorial caricature of an older police officer and a city official with oversized faces beside a scale weighing a pension plan and city budget
Editorial illustration
See the story visuallyThree quick views of this story

Visual summary

01 / At a glance

The main point

Allentown's police union is suing City Council. The fight is over a plan to keep older officers on the job.

02 / By the numbers

The number

20 years

Officers can retire after 20 years.

03 / Still unknown

What we don't know

The source did not report whether council voted to hire a lawyer, or when a court will hear the case.

Want the full context? Read the article ↓

Allentown's police union is suing City Council. The fight is over a plan to keep older officers on the job.

The plan is called the Deferred Retirement Officer Program, or Officers can retire after 20 years. DROP would let them keep working for up to five more years.

During that time, the city would set their pension payments aside. Officers would get that money in one lump sum when they fully retire.

About 15 officers are close to retiring, Police Chief Charles Roca said. The force has about 210 officers. That is roughly 7%.

Many of those officers agreed to stay if the city starts DROP, according to the lawsuit.

Mayor Matt Tuerk signed a deal with the union in February to create DROP. A new union contract starts next year. But council has not passed the law change DROP needs.

A bill to change the police pension law came up in June. Council met with city leaders and union officials in September. Members took no action. They had questions about long-term costs.

The Queen City Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 10 filed the suit. It names council and its seven members.

The lawsuit claims the mayor holds the power over labor deals. It claims council overstepped. It also claims council broke the union contract by not approving the mayor's deal.

The lawsuit says council's only job is to pass the law that carries out the deal. It says council has no power to block or redo it.

But the deal's first page says DROP starts only after council passes the pension changes. Tuerk and union president Sgt. Christopher Matthews signed that page.

Council President Santo Napoli and Vice President Cynthia Mota sent a statement by email. They said council can approve or reject changes to city union contracts. They said council will fight hard to defend that power. They said council must protect taxpayers' money over the long run.

Council could vote Wednesday to hire a lawyer to fight the suit.

In September, Matthews told council DROP “buys us time to ramp up our recruiting efforts.” He warned that many officers could leave at once.

Councilwoman Candida Affa said Sept. 9 that council needed real numbers before it could vote.

Auditing firm Maher Duessel studied the costs. It found DROP could add $1.1 million a year from 2028 to 2031. That is based on current retirement trends.

Costs could reach $3.5 million in 2031 if every officer joined as soon as allowed, according to the firm's projections.

The firm also said the city could lose more than $5 million in fees starting in 2028. That is because of a Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling. The court said stormwater fees work like a tax. Properties owned by governments and nonprofits could soon stop paying them.

DROP and the lost stormwater money could quickly eat into city savings, Maher Duessel found. City leaders could have to think about spending cuts and more tax increases.

Tuerk has proposed a 3.81% property tax increase in his 2027 budget. Council began reviewing it last month.

The city raised property taxes 3.96% for 2026. That was its first property tax increase in seven years.

What do you think?

Join the conversation. A nickname is optional; comments are reviewed for spam and safety.

Want more Lehigh Valley news in your Google results? Add Yooumad as a preferred source.