Lehigh Valley news. Straight up.

Lower Saucon's council president says the Bethlehem Landfill tried to "bully" the township. A court just tossed the landfill's case

A court dismissed the Bethlehem Landfill’s Sunshine Act appeal against Lower Saucon Township on procedural grounds.

A fictional adult township official with extreme 3D caricature features holds a court folder beside a gavel and distant landfill
Editorial illustration
See the story visuallyQuick views of this story

Visual summary

01 / Court result

Appeal dismissed

The Commonwealth Court threw out the landfill company’s Sunshine Act appeal.

02 / Reason

Filing steps

The judges did not decide the claims; they said the company did not follow the correct appeal steps.

03 / Still unknown

Another appeal?

The report did not say whether the company plans another appeal.

Want the full context? Read the article ↓

Lower Saucon Township has won another court fight with the Bethlehem Landfill.

The landfill company claimed township council members broke the Sunshine Act. That state law deals with open public meetings.

The Commonwealth Court threw out the case. The judges did not rule on whether the claims were true. They said the company did not follow the right steps when it filed its appeal.

The township and the landfill have fought in court for years.

The complaint was about a different lawsuit, known as the Petrie case. Council voted to switch sides in that case and back the landowners. The landfill said the switch was made at a meeting that was not open to the public.

The landfill also claimed that Council President Victoria Opthof-Cordaro was biased against it. It pointed to things she said while running for office.

Opthof-Cordaro said her votes were meant to protect landowners. She said they were not meant to help the landfill grow.

"It's an example of how a large company can try to come into a community and bully its way onto decisions that the council would need to make," she said.

She said the landfill wanted to keep her from voting with the rest of council. "They lost," she said.

"Not only did they lose at the trial court level, but they lost at the appellate level because they couldn't even follow the rules," she said.

Opthof-Cordaro said a bigger landfill now looks less and less likely. She said zoning and land deals that protect open space box it in to the east and west.

"I don't know what they plan to do, but I'm here to protect the residents," she said.

WFMZ reached out to the landfill's lead lawyer, Maryanne Garber. She did not respond.

What do you think?

Join the conversation. A nickname is optional; comments are reviewed for spam and safety.

Want more Lehigh Valley news in your Google results? Add Yooumad as a preferred source.