Lehigh Valley news. Straight up.

"We're not here to entertain people": Should Macungie residents get more time to speak at council?

Macungie Borough Council voted to extend public comment time from three minutes to four.

3D editorial caricature of fictional residents speaking before borough council beside a large clock
Editorial illustration
See the story visuallyThree quick views of this story

Visual summary

01 / At a glance

The main point

Macungie Borough Council voted to extend public comment time from three minutes to four.

02 / By the numbers

The number

4-2

Macungie Borough Council voted 4-2 on Nov. 2 to give residents four minutes to speak at meetings instead of three.

03 / Still unknown

What we don't know

How many residents spoke at the meeting was not reported. Whether any residents spoke against the new code of conduct was not reported.

Want the full context? Read the article ↓

Macungie Borough Council voted 4-2 on Nov. 2 to give residents four minutes to speak at meetings instead of three.

The change is part of new meeting rules. They cover public comment, how agendas are made and how people should behave at meetings.

Most of the debate was about the time limit. Some residents in the crowd could be heard saying four minutes was still not enough.

Council President Carl Sell Jr. wanted to keep the three-minute limit.

"I personally would like to still say three," Sell said. He said three minutes was enough time for residents.

Councilman Greg Hutchison also questioned giving more time.

"We're here to do business. We're not here to entertain people," Hutchison said.

Residents spoke about why it matters for the public to take part.

Under the rules, most regular meetings will have two times for public comment. One is near the start, for topics not on the agenda. The other comes before council votes on agenda items.

The rules also set a code of conduct. It applies to council members, borough workers and residents. It says everyone at meetings must be civil, orderly and respectful. It also lays out steps for dealing with people who disrupt meetings.

Resident Paul Licata asked whether council would have to answer questions raised during public comment.

The rules say public comment is not meant to be a question-and-answer time. Council members or staff may answer if they choose. But the rules say council will make a reasonable effort to have staff answer questions after the meeting.

The borough solicitor said changes to the state's open meetings law take effect in December. The changes will limit when towns can change a meeting agenda. Because of that, council removed wording about changing agendas from the rules.

Megan Sell, Stan Landis, Greg Reinbold and Thomas Ashelman voted yes. Carl Sell Jr. and Hutchison voted no. Council member Lynette Sell was absent.

Residents clapped after the vote. The rules took effect right away.

What do you think?

Join the conversation. A nickname is optional; comments are reviewed for spam and safety.

Want more Lehigh Valley news in your Google results? Add Yooumad as a preferred source.