Records say three deer heads sat in a Slate Belt freezer. Was it poaching? No hunting charges have been filed
A Slate Belt poaching investigation continues, while a separate firearm charge has been filed.

See the story visuallyThree quick views of this story
Visual summary
The main point
Investigators looking into deer poaching found three eight-point deer heads in a garage freezer at a Slate Belt home, court records say.
What else happened
As of Thursday afternoon, Stine had not been charged with any hunting crimes.
What we don't know
It is not known whether hunting charges will be filed or what the DNA tests found.
Want the full context? Read the article ↓
UPPER MOUNT BETHEL TWP., Pa. (Nov. 5, 2026) — Investigators looking into deer poaching found three eight-point deer heads in a garage freezer at a Slate Belt home, court records say.
The search took place at 7 a.m. Sunday at the Orchard Road home of Michael L. Stine, 55, records say. The Pennsylvania Game Commission led it with help from state police.
As of Thursday afternoon, Stine had not been charged with any hunting crimes.
State police did charge him Sunday with a felony for having a gun. Police said the search turned up a muzzleloader gun in a bedroom.
Stine cannot legally have guns because of felony convictions in Pennsylvania and New Jersey, court records state. Records say he told police the gun was his. He said he thought he was allowed to have it, records say.
He was released on $15,000 unsecured bail. A hearing is set for Dec. 2.
Stine declined to comment when a reporter called. A Game Commission spokesman did not answer questions Thursday about the case or whether more charges are coming.
The case began Oct. 25, a game warden wrote in court records. That day, the warden got video from a Ring camera on Gravel Hill Road near Bangor.
The video was shot about 10:15 the night before, the warden wrote. It shows a tall pickup truck with a beam of light. It also shows what may be an arrow or crossbow bolt flying into a field.
State law bars hunting with a bright light. It also bars hunting more than 30 minutes after sunset. That was about 6:38 p.m. that day, records say.
On Oct. 25, a caller who said he was Stine told a resident he had “shot a buck,” court records say. The resident later told the warden that Stine bragged about a $5,000 crossbow. The resident said its $1,800 scope had “night vision and a range finder built in.”
On Oct. 28, the warden found a blood trail near where the camera caught the truck, records say. A source also told the warden that two deer heads were in Stine's freezer without the tags the law requires.
Investigators also searched the Chelsea Sun Inn, a wedding venue in Upper Mount Bethel, records say. They found dried blood and hair that looked like deer. About 50 feet of cornstalks were damaged there, the warden wrote.
Investigators took blood and hair for DNA tests.
Two of the deer heads had tags from hunting permits, records say. The third had a handwritten tag.
Investigators left those heads at the home, along with crossbows, permits and other items, records say.
In September, a Northampton County judge ordered Stine to pay $20,000 to the state environmental agency over work done without permits on the Orchard Road land, the records show.
Your reaction
Want more Lehigh Valley news in your Google results? Add Yooumad as a preferred source.



What do you think?
Join the conversation. A nickname is optional; comments are reviewed for spam and safety.