Lehigh Valley news. Straight up.

Should Whitehall treat SMP Steaks as a restaurant or a retail store?

Whitehall’s zoning board will hear an appeal over whether SMP Steaks operates as a restaurant or retail shop.

Fictional extreme 3D caricatured steak shop owner and zoning official debate a storefront model
Editorial illustration
See the story visuallyThe SMP Steaks zoning dispute

Visual summary

01 / Hearing

Tuesday, Nov. 17

Whitehall’s zoning board is set to hear more about SMP Steaks.

02 / Dispute

Restaurant or store?

The township says restaurant; the owners say retail shop that sells sandwiches.

Want the full context? Read the article ↓

Whitehall's zoning board will hear more about SMP Steaks on Tuesday.

The shop is at 1050 Schadt Avenue. The township says it is running as a restaurant.

The township agenda for the Nov. 17 hearing states its claims. It says the shop lacks a use permit. It also says the shop lacks a special exception. And it says the shop does not have enough parking for its seats.

A use permit is township approval for how a property is used. A special exception is extra zoning approval that some uses need.

The owners say the shop is a retail store. They say it also sells sandwiches.

Zwaitini Inc. filed the appeal for SMP Steaks. The agenda says the company denies those claims. It says the company "asserts that it operates a retail store with incidental accessory sales of sandwiches." That means the company says sandwich sales are a side part of a store.

The hearing starts at 7 p.m. Tuesday. It will be at the township building at 3219 MacArthur Road. The agenda says the case was held over "to take additional evidence."

In a TikTok video posted Thursday, the SMP Mini Mart account asked people to come. The caption said, "Please come support us on Tuesday at 7pm for round 2 of our hearing in Whitehall."

Chade Sankari owns SMP Mini Mart on Mickley Road. He opened the Schadt Avenue shop in August, WFMZ said. That shop is known as SMP Steaks.

Sankari told WFMZ he got permits before the shop opened. He said inspectors also came and counted the seats. He said they told him which tables had to be accessible.

"We just followed exactly what we were told," Sankari told WFMZ.

He said an email came just days after the shop opened. It told him to close at once, he said. He said he was told he now needs a restaurant permit.

He said the Mickley Road shop is a deli and retail store. He said it has been approved that way for almost four years.

"We sell bread, we sell milk, we sell medicine," Sankari told WFMZ. "We sell what we said we were going to sell. It's all there."

The shop has stayed open during the appeal, WFMZ said. The station later said the shop can stay open. It can stay open until the board makes a final decision.

Sankari also told WFMZ he put up signs. The signs were meant to send extra cars to the Mickley Road lot. He said he was told the signs were illegal. He said he could be fined.

"I did hang signs up trying to guide my customers to park across the street," Sankari told WFMZ, "and I was informed that they're illegal signs and I could be fined for them to remove them."

Christopher Gittinger spoke at the Oct. 20 hearing, WFMZ said. He is the township's zoning and code enforcement officer. He said he got complaints about the business. He said he inspected it on Aug. 11.

"I went on Tuesday, August 11, and walked into the establishment. It was clearly a restaurant," Gittinger said, according to WFMZ. "I counted 42 seats inside and 16 seats outside."

"If you take into account the kitchen area where the food was prepared, it's more like 3-to-1 restaurant use compared to a retail setup," he said, according to WFMZ.

Lawyers asked Gittinger questions at the hearing, WFMZ said. He said the township code had no clear rule, the station said. It did not say what counts as a retail store or a restaurant. He also said the retail store permit had no food sale limit.

SMP lawyer Joel Wiener disagreed after the meeting.

Wiener said Gittinger was "trying to redefine 'retail store,'" according to WFMZ. He said Gittinger then walked in and said, "This is now a restaurant."

More than 60 people came to the Oct. 20 hearing. Some could not get inside, WFMZ said. After about 45 minutes, the board stopped the case. It said there was not enough time, the station said.

In October, Mayor Joseph Marx told WFMZ he could not comment. He said the matter was a ruling by zoning officers.

What do you think?

Join the conversation. A nickname is optional; comments are reviewed for spam and safety.

Want more Lehigh Valley news in your Google results? Add Yooumad as a preferred source.